New Jersey
Civil Justice Institute

  • Helpful Links
  • Contact Us
  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
    • Our Mission
    • Membership
    • Our Staff
  • ISSUES & ADVOCACY
  • OUR WORK IN THE COURTS
  • NEWSROOM
  • GET INVOLVED

Fairness. Justice.
Rule of Law.

NJCJI and ICNJ Joint Amicus Brief Accepted by the Supreme Court of New Jersey

October 22, 2021News, Recent News, Top StoriesNJCJI

On September 29, NJCJI joined the Insurance Council of New Jersey (ICNJ) in filing an amicus curiae brief with the New Jersey Supreme Court in Crystal Point Condo. Ass’n v. Kinsale Insurance. The Appellate Division’s opinion in that case eschewed New Jersey’s strong public policy in favor of arbitration and allowed the plaintiff, a third-party beneficiary to an insurance contract, who was suing the carrier through a direct action, to avoid the policy’s explicit arbitration provision.

In issuing its decision, the appellate panel asked more of the arbitration provision than it would an ordinary contract. This contradicts New Jersey and federal strong public policy in favor of arbitration agreements, which requires courts to apply traditional state-contract law standards to arbitration agreements. The panel appeared to require explicit mutual assent between a third-party beneficiary and an insurer. This is an unprecedented and improper burden to place on parties agreeing to arbitrate in this context. Placing such burdens on arbitration provisions will also result in unpredictability in enforcing arbitration provisions, resulting in more litigation, increased costs and higher insurance premiums. NJCJI and ICNJ have asked the Court to restore arbitration to its status as a preferred dispute resolution method and to remind New Jersey courts of the traditional principles governing arbitration agreements.

On October 22, the Supreme Court issued its order granting NJCJI and ICNJ’s motion to participate as amici curiae and accepted the joint brief for filing.

A copy of the brief can be found below:

Crystal Point Condo. Ass’n v. Kinsale Ins. Co. – Brief by Amici Curiae NJCJI and ICNJDownload

Newsletter Sign Up




© 2022 NJCJI. All rights reserved.

Follow us on:

  • twitter
  • linkedin

TWITTER FEED TWITTER FEED

  • https://t.co/DlWbCRFBea, Jul 1
  • https://t.co/xl0stnCZfj NJCJI President Anthony Anastasio testified this week about the implications of NJ Senate… https://t.co/o55d5pA29b, Jun 24
  • https://t.co/x2z9vrW707 Thank you to @PPAGInc, @GenovaBurns, and @PBWTLaw for your support of the 2022 Spring Event!, Jun 21
  • Institute for Legal Reform Releases Update on Third-Party Litigation Funding https://t.co/UQDqeUQ712, Apr 15
  • The American Tort Reform Association issued a report about the National Association of Attorneys General. https://t.co/14sYVCKPrY, Apr 8

    QUICK CONTACT



    Please enter the code as shown below

    captcha

    New Jersey Civil Justice Institute | 112 West State Street, Trenton, NJ 08608 | office: (609) 218-6331 | info@civiljusticenj.org