New Jersey
Civil Justice Institute

  • Helpful Links
  • Contact Us
  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
    • Our Mission
    • Membership
    • Our Staff
  • ISSUES & ADVOCACY
  • OUR WORK IN THE COURTS
  • NEWSROOM
  • GET INVOLVED

Fairness. Justice.
Rule of Law.

Third Circuit Reiterates Product Liability Act Bars Some CFA Claims

December 3, 2020News, Recent News, Top StoriesNJCJI

In a recent published opinion, the Third Circuit (echoing a July 29, 2020 opinion from the New Jersey Supreme Court) held that some claims brought under the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act are subsumed by the New Jersey Products Liability Act, while others are not. NJCJI previously reported on this issue and hosted a webinar with Gavin Rooney, Lowenstein Sandler and Jeff Jacobson, Faegre Drinker.

  • Sun Chemical Corp. v. Fike Corp., ___ F.3d ___ (3rd Cir. Nov. 27, 2020) https://www2.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/181062p.pdf (Third Circuit opinion);
  • Sun Chemical Corp. v. Fike Corp., 235 A.3d 145, ___ N.J. ___ (N.J. July 29, 2020) https://www.njcourts.gov/attorneys/assets/opinions/supreme/a_89_18.pdf?c=WlJ (state Supreme Court opinion).

The Third Circuit explained that, according to the state Supreme Court, “allegations of fraudulent or unconscionable business practices could support a CFA claim, whereas claims based solely on a product’s ‘manufacturing, warning, or design defect’ would be actionable only under the PLA.”  Third Circuit Op. at 8 (emphasis added).  “Because the claims would rest on different theories of liability and would be premised on different types of conduct, the [state Supreme Court] held that a plaintiff could maintain both causes of action in a single suit.”  Id.

The question turns on “the underlying theory of liability.”  Third Circuit Op. at 8.  “[A] CFA claim alleging express misrepresentations­–deceptive, fraudulent, misleading, and other unconscionable commercial practices–may be brought in the same action as a PLA claim premised upon product manufacturing, warning, or design defects. In other words, the PLA will not bar a CFA claim alleging express or affirmative misrepresentations.”  Id. 

In conclusion, the Court explained, the PLA does not subsume claims premised on affirmative misrepresentations rather than on a deficiency in the product itself.  Id. at 15-16.

Should you wish to discuss this matter in further detail contact Shalom Stone, Stone Conroy, 973-400-4182 or sstone@stoneconroy.com.

Categories

    Press Releases
    Recent News
    Top Stories

Tag Cloud

Appeal Bond Cap | Arbitration | Attorney Fees | Ban the Box | Bankruptcy Trust | Business Climate | CFA | Civil Justice | Class Actions | CLE | Congress | Damages | Double Dipping | Expert Evidence | Fee Shifting | Food Law | Good Samaritan Bill | Governor Christie | Governor Murphy | Insurance | Judicial Independence | Judicial Selection | Juries | Legal Reform | Medical & Pharmaceutical Liability | Medical Liability | New Jersey Bar Association | New Jersey Courts | New Jersey Legislature | New Jersey Supreme Court | NJCJI | Outrageous Lawsuits | Paid Sick Leave | Personal Jurisdiction | Pharmaceutical Litigation | Regulation via Litigation | Rule of Law | SCOTUS | Settlement Trust Transparency | Statute of Limitations | TCCWNA | Third Circuit | Tort Reform | Trial Lawyers | Wrongful Death

Newsletter Sign Up




© 2021 NJCJI. All rights reserved.

Follow us on:

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin

TWITTER FEED TWITTER FEED

  • With our recent President change, NJCJI NJCJI would like to ensure we have the most up-to-date contact information… https://t.co/a5PWkhEUyG, Jan 8
  • RT @ROINJNews: Anastasio named new president of @NJCivilJustice. https://t.co/7EsKJxgvhF, Jan 4
  • Pfizer and BioNTech say their coronavirus vaccine was 95% effective with no safety concerns - CNN https://t.co/zPywNd3Xrt, Nov 18
  • Now that the election is over, can we fix our federal courts? | Opinion - https://t.co/TSDmkRcHG3 https://t.co/2D99jDkLhi, Nov 16
  • Pfizer’s Early Data Shows Coronavirus Vaccine Is More Than 90% Effective - The New York Times https://t.co/G5CY8sU1LP, Nov 10

QUICK CONTACT



Please enter the code as shown below

captcha

New Jersey Civil Justice Institute | 112 West State Street, Trenton, NJ 08608 | office: (609) 392-6557 | info@civiljusticenj.org