New Jersey
Civil Justice Institute

  • Helpful Links
  • Contact Us
  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
    • Our Mission
    • Membership
    • Our Staff
  • ISSUES & ADVOCACY
  • OUR WORK IN THE COURTS
  • NEWSROOM
  • GET INVOLVED

Fairness. Justice.
Rule of Law.

A Fraud On Us All

February 16, 2018News, Top StoriesCFA, Legal ReformNJCJI

In her Inquirer article on the Consumer Fraud Act-based Super Bowl ticket lawsuit, author Jan Hefler optimistically asserts, “A ruling in the fan’s favor could also lead to lower ticket prices the next time the Super Bowl is held at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, N.J.” That the court recently ruled in the fan’s favor is true. Whether it will lead to lower ticket prices in the future is a more complicated question.

 

The plaintiff is arguing that the NFL’s failure to make Super Bowl tickets more widely available to the general public has the effect of artificially inflating ticket prices on the secondary market.  The Third Circuit concluded that the plaintiff’s economic theory was sufficiently plausible to allow case to go ahead: that withholding tickets resulted in those tickets being redirected to third-party brokers, who were able to charge higher prices on resale than if the secondary market were supplied by more individual sellers.

 

Whatever the economic merits of plaintiff’s theory, selling high-demand tickets directly to fans and avoiding scalpers and bots has also been something of a technical challenge. As NFL points out, “many more people desire to attend the Super Bowl each year than can be seated at Super Bowl host stadiums,” and that excess demand for limited-supply events creates a significant incentive for scalpers to find ways to dominate the primary market.

 

Event hosts and performers have begun experimenting with innovative techniques like Verified Fan sales – using algorithms to identify potential purchasers less likely to re-sell their tickets – with some success. Bruce Springsteen, for example, used the Verified Fan distribution model for his recent Broadway run.  But the legislature’s decision to micromanage the mechanisms by which tickets are sold now risks blocking such innovations.

 

It is not clear that the Verified Fan model would comply with the CFA’s ticket sales provision, and its adoption may very well be subject to future litigation, with the risk of CFA mandatory treble damages.  The micromanagement of business practices, combined with the risk of massive financial penalties, discourages innovation and limits options that could benefit consumers and businesses alike.

 

It is time to make some thoughtful changes to our state’s consumer protection laws. There is an imbalance between protecting consumers and encouraging innovation, and all of us are suffering as a result.

 

Categories

    Press Releases
    Recent News
    Top Stories

Tag Cloud

Appeal Bond Cap | Arbitration | Attorney Fees | Bad Faith | Ban the Box | Bankruptcy Trust | Business Climate | CFA | Civil Justice | Class Actions | CLE | Damages | Discovery | Double Dipping | Employment Law | Expert Evidence | Fee Shifting | Food Law | Good Samaritan Bill | Governor Christie | Governor Murphy | Insurance | Judicial Selection | Juries | Medical & Pharmaceutical Liability | Medical Liability | New Jersey Bar Association | New Jersey Courts | New Jersey Legislature | New Jersey Supreme Court | NJCJI | Outrageous Lawsuits | Paid Sick Leave | Personal Jurisdiction | Pharmaceutical Litigation | Policy Teleforum | Regulation via Litigation | SCOTUS | Settlement Trust Transparency | Statute of Limitations | TCCWNA | Third Circuit | Tort Reform | Trial Lawyers | Wrongful Death

Newsletter Sign Up




© 2021 NJCJI. All rights reserved.

Follow us on:

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin

TWITTER FEED TWITTER FEED

  • US Chamber and NJCJI Win Major Arbitration Case in NJ https://t.co/kNwABykb7i, Mar 26
  • https://t.co/3hRvGgjesg, Mar 12
  • https://t.co/9EDd0NzmNe, Mar 12
  • NJBIZ Conversations: Anthony Anastasio - NJBIZ ⁦@NJBIZ⁩ https://t.co/gdne9pyxYB, Feb 3
  • With our recent President change, NJCJI NJCJI would like to ensure we have the most up-to-date contact information… https://t.co/a5PWkhEUyG, Jan 8

QUICK CONTACT



Please enter the code as shown below

captcha

New Jersey Civil Justice Institute | 112 West State Street, Trenton, NJ 08608 | office: (609) 392-6557 | info@civiljusticenj.org